To catch a predator

Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) has long been heralded as a sanctuary for those battling alcohol addiction, providing a supportive, peer-led community where individuals can work toward sobriety. However, beneath the surface of this trusted and essential organization lies a disturbing issue that has emerged in various AA groups: the presence of sexual and emotional predators. This problem is often brushed aside or overlooked, but it poses significant risks to vulnerable members who seek recovery, trust, and community. In this essay, we will explore the roots of this problem, its implications for AA as a whole, and potential solutions to mitigate the risk to individuals attending meetings.

The Role of Alcoholics Anonymous: A Background

Founded in 1935 by Bill Wilson and Dr. Bob Smith, Alcoholics Anonymous was created as a fellowship where men and women could come together to support each other in their shared journey toward sobriety. AA operates through a series of steps—the famous 12 steps—that emphasize personal accountability, spiritual growth, and mutual aid. Meetings are designed to be safe spaces for sharing personal stories, struggles, and hopes for recovery, while the principle of anonymity helps to protect individuals' privacy.

AA has helped millions of people worldwide. The organization’s decentralized structure allows it to exist as a grassroots movement, where individual groups function autonomously. However, this autonomy, while offering flexibility and inclusivity, has also created vulnerabilities. Without centralized oversight or strong accountability measures in place, individual AA groups can become breeding grounds for inappropriate behavior, particularly in the form of predatory actions by a minority of attendees.

Understanding Predatory Behavior in AA

The problem of predators in AA is a sensitive but critical issue. In the context of AA, a predator is someone who exploits vulnerable individuals—often newcomers—for personal gain, whether that be emotional manipulation, sexual exploitation, or coercion. New members of AA, who are typically in early recovery, are especially vulnerable due to the emotional and psychological fragility that often accompanies early sobriety. These individuals might be dealing with trauma, shame, low self-esteem, and a profound need for belonging, making them susceptible to those who may take advantage of their situation.

Predatory behavior in AA can manifest in different ways:

Sexual Predation: This is the most commonly reported form of predatory behavior in AA. Some individuals target newcomers, often women, offering them support or mentorship with the hidden agenda of pursuing sexual relationships. New members may mistake these advances for genuine help and might not have the emotional fortitude to recognize or reject inappropriate behavior.
Emotional Manipulation: In some cases, individuals exploit the power dynamics in AA to manipulate others emotionally. By positioning themselves as trusted mentors or confidants, they may gain control over vulnerable members, steering them toward unhealthy or harmful relationships that exploit the newcomer’s emotional state.
Financial Exploitation: In certain situations, predators in AA might seek financial gain, manipulating individuals into lending money or providing resources under the guise of friendship or mentorship.

The anonymity that protects members also protects predators, as it allows them to operate in relative obscurity. This dynamic complicates the ability of the community to hold individuals accountable, as anonymity is central to the ethos of AA.

The Impact on Vulnerable Members

For many individuals, attending an AA meeting for the first time can be an overwhelming experience. They are often at rock bottom, having been damaged by years of addiction, isolation, and emotional turmoil. The psychological vulnerability of such individuals makes them prime targets for predatory behavior.

The impact of such exploitation can be devastating. Survivors of predatory behavior in AA may experience feelings of betrayal, confusion, guilt, and shame, all of which can undermine their recovery. In some cases, individuals may leave AA altogether, losing access to the crucial support that AA provides, which can result in relapse or deepening isolation. The violation of trust is especially harmful in this context, as trust is a central pillar of the recovery process in AA.

Moreover, the presence of predators within AA meetings can create a toxic environment where individuals do not feel safe to share their struggles openly. The fear of being targeted can prevent newcomers from engaging fully with the process, which can hinder their recovery. Long-term, this can also damage the overall reputation of AA, as stories of predatory behavior within the organization can discourage others from seeking help.

Why the Problem Persists

Several factors contribute to the persistence of predatory behavior in AA:

Anonymity and Lack of Accountability: AA’s cornerstone principle is anonymity, which protects members' privacy but can also shield predators from consequences. Since AA groups are autonomous and self-regulating, there is often no formal mechanism to report or address inappropriate behavior. This creates an environment where predatory actions can go unchecked.
Power Imbalances: Predators in AA often exploit the power imbalances that naturally arise in the sponsor-sponsee relationship. A sponsor is someone who provides guidance to a sponsee, helping them work through the 12 steps and offering emotional support. This relationship can create a dependency, which some sponsors may exploit for personal gain.
Gender Dynamics: Sexual predation in AA often follows gendered lines, with male members exploiting female newcomers. While this is not always the case, the power dynamics between male sponsors and female sponsees have been highlighted as a particular concern. The intimate nature of the sponsor-sponsee relationship—where personal stories and vulnerabilities are shared—can make women especially susceptible to exploitation.
Cultural Norms within AA: There is a longstanding cultural emphasis within AA on forgiveness, tolerance, and giving people the benefit of the doubt, which can inadvertently enable predatory behavior. Individuals may be reluctant to report inappropriate actions because they fear they will not be believed, or they may be encouraged to forgive the predator rather than address the behavior.
The Newcomer Vulnerability: Many of those entering AA are at a particularly vulnerable point in their lives. They may be experiencing withdrawal, emotional instability, and a deep sense of shame and guilt. Their eagerness to find support and acceptance makes them easy targets for predators who offer assistance with ulterior motives.

Real-Life Testimonies and Reports

Over the years, numerous testimonies have surfaced from individuals who have experienced predatory behavior within AA. Many of these testimonies point to a pattern of abuse that often goes unaddressed due to the decentralized nature of the organization.

One such example is the phenomenon of "13th-stepping." In AA slang, this refers to older, more experienced members (often men) pursuing romantic or sexual relationships with newer, more vulnerable members (often women). While relationships between consenting adults are not inherently problematic, the issue arises when these relationships involve manipulation, coercion, or exploitation of power imbalances. The term “13th-stepping” has become synonymous with predatory behavior in AA, and its widespread use indicates that the issue is far from isolated.

Research studies and news articles have also highlighted the issue. A 2011 article in The Atlantic brought attention to multiple cases of sexual predation within AA, detailing how predators exploit the anonymity of the group and the vulnerability of newcomers to target potential victims. Similarly, various lawsuits have been filed against AA groups or specific individuals within them, alleging sexual misconduct.

The Need for Structural Reforms and Safeguards

Despite the decentralized nature of AA, there are steps that can be taken to address the problem of predators within the organization. Here are a few potential reforms and safeguards that could help mitigate the risks to vulnerable members:

Education and Awareness: Raising awareness about the problem of predatory behavior within AA is a crucial first step. This could involve workshops, educational materials, and discussions during meetings that emphasize the importance of consent, boundaries, and the power dynamics that can exist in sponsor-sponsee relationships. Awareness of predatory behavior could empower members to recognize warning signs and protect themselves and others.
Codes of Conduct: While AA prides itself on its lack of formal rules, establishing voluntary codes of conduct could help set expectations for appropriate behavior. These codes could outline boundaries between members, particularly in sponsor-sponsee relationships, and offer guidance on how to report and address inappropriate behavior.
Reporting Mechanisms: One of the biggest challenges in addressing predatory behavior in AA is the lack of formal reporting mechanisms. Establishing a system where individuals can report inappropriate behavior without fear of retribution or exposure could be a game-changer. This could take the form of a confidential hotline or a designated group of members tasked with handling complaints.
Peer Accountability Groups: Encouraging peer accountability within AA groups could help create a safer environment. This might involve forming committees or designated members who are responsible for monitoring group dynamics and addressing concerns related to predatory behavior. While this would need to be done delicately to preserve AA’s spirit of mutual support, it could foster a greater sense of responsibility among members.
Separate Spaces for Vulnerable Populations: Offering women-only, LGBTQ+, or other specific groups could provide safer spaces for vulnerable populations within AA. These meetings could reduce the risk of predatory behavior by allowing individuals to share their experiences without the fear of being targeted by predators.
Sponsorship Guidelines: Given the power dynamics that exist in sponsor-sponsee relationships, providing clear guidelines for sponsorship could help prevent exploitation. For example, discouraging romantic or sexual relationships between sponsors and sponsees during the early stages of recovery might help reduce the risk of abuse.

Conclusion

The problem of predators in Alcoholics Anonymous is a deeply troubling issue that undermines the organization's mission to help individuals recover from addiction in a supportive, safe, and nurturing environment. While the decentralized and anonymous nature of AA has allowed it to grow into a global movement, it has also created vulnerabilities that predators can exploit.

Addressing this issue will require a multifaceted approach that balances AA's emphasis on anonymity and mutual support with the need for greater accountability and protection for vulnerable members. Education, reporting mechanisms, peer accountability, and guidelines for behavior are just a few ways to begin addressing this issue. Ultimately, the safety and well-being of all AA members, particularly the most vulnerable, must be prioritized to ensure that the organization continues to provide a haven for those seeking recovery.

—

Need words? Make contact.

Review portfolio and a list of services